Thyroid patients are being harmed by failures in prescribing of drug, liothyronine, says new report
|
26th November 2018
A widespread failure of local NHS bodies to consistently follow national guidelines on the prescribing of a thyroid drug is causing harm to patients, says a significant new report published today. The report shows that liothyronine, a drug used in the treatment of underactive thyroid (hypothyroidism), is not being routinely provided across the country to the people who need it. Read the full dossier here: bit.ly/LiothyronineDossier2018 The evidence gathered shows that vulnerable people have ended up with depression, diabetes, heart problems, weight gain, high cholesterol and exhaustion from having this drug either taken away or not prescribed in the first place. The case studies also show people being unable to work and trying to find ways of funding the drug privately. This is all despite NHS England approved guidance from last year stating that liothyronine should be provided to those who really need it. The report, which was requested by the Department of Health, has been produced by a consortium of thyroid patient organisations, with guidance from the British Thyroid Association – the UK’s body for thyroid specialists. The organisations received over 400 patients’ stories that showed how local NHS Clinical Commissioning Groups are not following the national NHS England approved guidance. Patients who have had liothyronine withdrawn said, “Like thousands of other UK patients, I cannot have a prescription for T3 from my GP or my endocrinologist. I am left in a frightening place.” “Life without liothyronine for me is no life at all.” “I feel completely abandoned by the National Health Service.” |
|
The report – “Liothyronine – Case Details with Clear Evidence that NHS England Guidance on Prescription of Liothyronine is not Being Followed by CCGs”, follows the House of Lords debate led by Lord Hunt of Kings Heath [3], when Lord O’Shaughnessy, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, requested clear evidence that NHS England Guidance is not being followed by CCGs. The report has now been handed to NHS England.
Dr Krishna Chatterjee, Professor of Endocrinology and president of the British Thyroid Association states, “The current uncertainty, with liothyronine-treated individuals either being denied ongoing prescriptions or needing to source the treatment themselves at their own cost, seems very much against patients’ interests.”
Lord Hunt stated, "The evidence is clear that there are some NHS patients who need to have access to liothyronine. NHS England have accepted at a national level but the message just isn’t getting through at a local level. It’s not acceptable that vulnerable people are getting caught up in something that should have easily been avoided."
The authors of the report are now calling for NHS England to exercise its formal powers to intervene on behalf of patients and ensure that those who need liothyronine have clear access to it through the NHS, regardless of which CCG they come under.
Ends
Notes for editors:
About hypothyroidism
Liothyronine, the medicines value programme consultation and guidance
This story started when Liothyronine was included in an NHS England consultation last year, as part of the medicines value programme work [2], the consultation heard from a large number of patients and professionals about liothyronine and concluded with guidance that patients with hypothyroidism who require liothyronine, because it helps them and the standard treatment of levothyroxine has not worked for them, should continue to have it. Guidance from British Thyroid Association is included in the national guidance, stating clearly that patients deriving benefit from liothyronine should not have their treatment disrupted. Unfortunately many CCGs and Regional Medicines Optimisation Committee have subsequently developed separate guidelines which either exclude or obscure the BTA guidance, causing patients to be denied treatment. The report authors reviewed over 100 such separate NHS documents on this one medicine.
Cost
CCGs have been seeking to limit prescribing of liothyronine since the cost increased by 6000% in the UK. Despite costing only a few euros in other European countries, the NHS is paying significantly more for reasons which are unclear. [6]
New Analysis of prescribing data
A new analysis of NHS prescribing data by Dr Peter Taylor of Cardiff University’s Institute of Molecular & Experimental Medicine features in the report and demonstrates that UK prescribing of liothyronine has dropped dramatically in recent years, particularly in areas of the greatest deprivation. Submitted for publication.
Links:
[1] Report: Liothyronine – Case Details with Clear Evidence that NHS England Guidance on
Prescription of Liothyronine is not Being Followed by CCGs bit.ly/LiothyronineDossier2018
[2] NHS England guidance https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/items-which-should-not-be-routinely-precscribed-in-pc-ccg-guidance.pdf
Also see British Thyroid Association guidance (linked to in the above) https://www.british-thyroid-association.org/current-bta-guidelines-
[3] Regret Debate: Hansard: Branded Health Service Medicines (Costs) Regulations 2018 http://bit.ly/2vPBSqs
[4] Hypothyroidism information and stats https://patient.info/health/thyroid-and-parathyroid-glands/underactive-thyroid-gland-hypothyroidism
[5] 2018 Study into patient satisfaction with treatments for hypothyroidism https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29620972
[6] ‘Drug firm Concordia overcharged NHS with 6000% price rise, says watchdog,’ The Guardian, 21 November 2017. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/nov/21/drug-firm-concordia-overcharged-nhs-with-6000-price-rise
Contributing authors:
British Thyroid Association, Public Address: Professor Krishna Chatterjee (President) or Dr Carla Moran (Secretary) , Institute of Metabolic Science, Box 289, Addenbrookes Hospital, Hills Rd, Cambridge, CB2 0QQ Charity Number. 1119631
British Thyroid Foundation, Suite 12, One Sceptre House, Hornbeam Square North, Hornbeam Park, Harrogate HG2 8PB Registered Charity England & Wales Number 1006391, Scotland SC046037
Improve Thyroid Treatment Campaign Group, contact via The Thyroid Trust
Midlands Thyroid Support Group, contact via Thyroid UK
Thyroid Support Group Norfolk, 16, Alston Road, Hellesdon Park, Norwich NR6 5DS
Thyroid Patient Advocacy, 67 Clearmount Road, Weymouth, DT4 9LE Registered Charity Number 1138608
The Thyroid Trust, 15 Great College Street, London, SW1P 3RX (Working towards registering as a Charitable Incorporated Organisation)
Thyroid UK, 32 Darcy Road, St Osyth, Clacton on Sea, Essex CO16 8QF Registered Charity Number 1125270
Dr Krishna Chatterjee, Professor of Endocrinology and president of the British Thyroid Association states, “The current uncertainty, with liothyronine-treated individuals either being denied ongoing prescriptions or needing to source the treatment themselves at their own cost, seems very much against patients’ interests.”
Lord Hunt stated, "The evidence is clear that there are some NHS patients who need to have access to liothyronine. NHS England have accepted at a national level but the message just isn’t getting through at a local level. It’s not acceptable that vulnerable people are getting caught up in something that should have easily been avoided."
The authors of the report are now calling for NHS England to exercise its formal powers to intervene on behalf of patients and ensure that those who need liothyronine have clear access to it through the NHS, regardless of which CCG they come under.
Ends
Notes for editors:
About hypothyroidism
- Hypothyroidism is a lifelong condition requiring daily thyroid hormone replacement. The standard treatment is with a synthetic version of the thyroid hormone, thyroxine.
- Thyroxine is normally converted into the active hormone, liothyronine, in the body, but some patients need to take synthetic liothyronine when that conversion process does not work properly.
- Treatment with liothyronine, a completely different thyroid hormone replacement to levothyroxine, is often more effective in a minority of patients - either alone or in combination with levothyroxine - although the reasons for this are not yet fully understood. If levothyroxine does not resolve symptoms, then the addition of liothyronine is the only alternative.
- Levothyroxine is the second most prescribed item by the NHS (2017).
- Hypothyroidism is ten times more common in women than it is in men. In the UK, around 1-2 in 100 people have hypothyroidism. It most commonly develops in adult women and becomes more common with increasing age. However, it can occur at any age and can affect anyone. [4]
- Studies indicate that 1 in 10 patients with hypothyroidism may only be returned to health by the use of liothyronine. [5]
Liothyronine, the medicines value programme consultation and guidance
This story started when Liothyronine was included in an NHS England consultation last year, as part of the medicines value programme work [2], the consultation heard from a large number of patients and professionals about liothyronine and concluded with guidance that patients with hypothyroidism who require liothyronine, because it helps them and the standard treatment of levothyroxine has not worked for them, should continue to have it. Guidance from British Thyroid Association is included in the national guidance, stating clearly that patients deriving benefit from liothyronine should not have their treatment disrupted. Unfortunately many CCGs and Regional Medicines Optimisation Committee have subsequently developed separate guidelines which either exclude or obscure the BTA guidance, causing patients to be denied treatment. The report authors reviewed over 100 such separate NHS documents on this one medicine.
Cost
CCGs have been seeking to limit prescribing of liothyronine since the cost increased by 6000% in the UK. Despite costing only a few euros in other European countries, the NHS is paying significantly more for reasons which are unclear. [6]
New Analysis of prescribing data
A new analysis of NHS prescribing data by Dr Peter Taylor of Cardiff University’s Institute of Molecular & Experimental Medicine features in the report and demonstrates that UK prescribing of liothyronine has dropped dramatically in recent years, particularly in areas of the greatest deprivation. Submitted for publication.
Links:
[1] Report: Liothyronine – Case Details with Clear Evidence that NHS England Guidance on
Prescription of Liothyronine is not Being Followed by CCGs bit.ly/LiothyronineDossier2018
[2] NHS England guidance https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/items-which-should-not-be-routinely-precscribed-in-pc-ccg-guidance.pdf
Also see British Thyroid Association guidance (linked to in the above) https://www.british-thyroid-association.org/current-bta-guidelines-
[3] Regret Debate: Hansard: Branded Health Service Medicines (Costs) Regulations 2018 http://bit.ly/2vPBSqs
[4] Hypothyroidism information and stats https://patient.info/health/thyroid-and-parathyroid-glands/underactive-thyroid-gland-hypothyroidism
[5] 2018 Study into patient satisfaction with treatments for hypothyroidism https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29620972
[6] ‘Drug firm Concordia overcharged NHS with 6000% price rise, says watchdog,’ The Guardian, 21 November 2017. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/nov/21/drug-firm-concordia-overcharged-nhs-with-6000-price-rise
Contributing authors:
British Thyroid Association, Public Address: Professor Krishna Chatterjee (President) or Dr Carla Moran (Secretary) , Institute of Metabolic Science, Box 289, Addenbrookes Hospital, Hills Rd, Cambridge, CB2 0QQ Charity Number. 1119631
British Thyroid Foundation, Suite 12, One Sceptre House, Hornbeam Square North, Hornbeam Park, Harrogate HG2 8PB Registered Charity England & Wales Number 1006391, Scotland SC046037
Improve Thyroid Treatment Campaign Group, contact via The Thyroid Trust
Midlands Thyroid Support Group, contact via Thyroid UK
Thyroid Support Group Norfolk, 16, Alston Road, Hellesdon Park, Norwich NR6 5DS
Thyroid Patient Advocacy, 67 Clearmount Road, Weymouth, DT4 9LE Registered Charity Number 1138608
The Thyroid Trust, 15 Great College Street, London, SW1P 3RX (Working towards registering as a Charitable Incorporated Organisation)
Thyroid UK, 32 Darcy Road, St Osyth, Clacton on Sea, Essex CO16 8QF Registered Charity Number 1125270
for everyone affected by thyroid disease
Correspondence ADDRESS71-75 Shelton Street, London, WC2H 9JQ
The Thyroid Trust is also known as Thyroid Friends Network,
it is our intention to register as a charitable incorporated organisation in the coming months. copyright asserted 2019 - Our consititution and all policy documents can be viewed on request. Read our Privacy Policy updated 23/5/18, |
|